Greece: The Folly of Central Planning

Blog Post
America’s founders, now characterized as “rich white men”, as if that was an indictment, understood that government needed to offer the maximum flexibility and freedom. They created a system that was federated (layered). Each layer had its responsibilities. Each enacted laws particular to the needs and ambitions of its constituents. Each elected citizens to serve to oversee the level and function of government that it needed. The Constitution enumerated what the National government was responsible and EVERYTHING else was left to the individual states to decide. The Bill of Rights and a Supreme Court was set up to insure that the system was fair and the playing field, even.
America was not designed to have a massive central government that took money in and then redistributed that money to buy votes. Central planning doesn’t work. The nation is too complicated, the people too diverse and the system too complex. There is a lesson here that the Europeans are learning to their detriment, as they try to reinvent the wheel.

(Fox News) GREECE’S WORSENING debt crisis sends shivers through American stock markets, a day after Greek voters reject demands from international creditors for further austerity measures in exchange for a bailout of its bankrupt economy.

The Wisdom of Bankers and Planners?

The soul-searing lesson of the fall of the Soviet Union and the Warsaw Pact is that central planning of a national economy or of a set of linked national economies exceeds the wisdom and wit of economists, bankers and financial experts. The European Union and its economic advisors and agencies failed to learn that lesson. Elite leaders are simply not smart enough to control or even anticipate the choices of free people.
On 5 July, more than 60% of Greek voters voted OXI, which is pronounced, “oh-key,” which is translated, “no.” 
For the second time, voters approved the anti-austerity party and policies by a large majority. The electoral mandate of the Syriza Party has been reaffirmed by a large margin. That mandate is that the austerity programs designed in bureaucratic offices by unelected functionaries has failed and will not be continued in Greece.
Greece has not settled its debts or solved its economic problems, but its voters have voted for Greece over Europe and in that expression of political will have reclaimed their national sovereignty. That changes everything. Greece will still owe Euro-denominated debts. On the other hand, its leaders have a strong mandate to repudiate Euro-mandated rules in settling them. 

The Greek voters just said that the Brussels bankers are not sovereign. That converts the forthcoming economic negotiations into a traditional model of sovereign vs bankers. The European Union, the European Central Bank and the International Monetary Fund came close to emasculating the idea of national sovereignty in the guise of debt settlement. 

Looking ahead, the Greeks will do fine. At least half the Greek national GDP is off the books. The grey economy is flexible, corrupt and responsive. Greeks know how to survive. Most TV narratives will not convey that message.
The BBC and other analysts have written that past bailouts for Greece actually exceed the total amount of Greek national debt. The debt service rates attached to the loans, however, resulted in 90% of the loans being committed to paying off debt service to the lenders. Less than 10% of the European loans remained to pay pensions or other sovereign obligations. This was a rigged system.

Five years of European bailouts produced deeper indebtedness without any improvement in the Greek Gross Domestic Product. Greek bailouts have been an economic shell game that profited the lenders.

The near term consequences will be negotiations among the Europeans over another Greek bailout, so as to avoid acknowledging their colossal failure of judgment. There will emerge new opportunities for profits with Greek entrepreneurs and consumers, if Greece returns to free market economic policies.
US Investor Exposure
US investors hold only about $10 billion of Greece’s $330 bn debt. This is pocket change relative to the US debt. The largest threat is that other debtor states, whose population is tired of austerity policies that have not failed, will follow the Greek example. A domino effect could lead to more serious consequences for US investors, especially if the Greek way leads to prosperity instead of perpetual poverty.

Something to think about:

4 thoughts on “Greece: The Folly of Central Planning

  1. "Greek bailouts have been an economic shell game that profited the lenders." I should certainly hope that lenders should see profit, and big gobs of the stuff at that, considering the risk they take dealing with Greeks.

    I hope that Greece indeed tells Brussels to shove it. US exposure is minimal, and the Euro may see its comeupence. (a word?). The Euro was a bad idea from the start, anyway. I kind of liked the Deutschmark, back in the day.

  2. The Swiss and the Brits were smart to keep their own currency. The Greeks will certainly go back to the Drachma, having bled Europe.

    As with many debt situations we saw (such as the sub-prime loans that wrecked the US Economy), you can hurt people as much as you helping by loaning them money. Such was the situation with Greece.

  3. In our new economic system, the more in debt you are the richer you'll be. It's a bit like global warming climate change disruption, which has made everything colder, because it's hotter.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to top