Is Afghanistan Lost?

Blog Post
The comment of anyone familiar with history will say that of course it’s lost. If the British couldn’t hold it in successive wars, and the Russians couldn’t hold it, what makes us think that our investment in time, treasure and lives would have a different outcome? 
When President Obama came into office, he declared that the war in Afghanistan was a “good war” and put his stamp on it. I chuckled at the time because war is a racket and I knew that Obama would turn tail and pull out as soon as we’d spent enough money lives in a worthless endeavor. I am not discounting the lives of Americans and Afghan allies. I simply point to the loss of Ramadi, Iraq and the Obama Administration’s assertion “at this point what difference does it make?” — and suggest that the same thing is happening in Afghanistan.
The litmus test for the value of a war is when the sons and grandsons of members of the US Congress, and possibly Chelsea Clinton and her ilk, are sent to the front lines in that war to offer up their lives for flag and country. Until THAT happens, lives and treasure will be freely spilled to no lasting effect…much like Viet Nam.

There are some who say that the long war in Afghanistan was a pay-back for the 9/11 terror attack. The only problem with that is that the attack was generated by Saudis and Saudi Arabia was our “ally” and oil supplier. We couldn’t very well go there and root out the Wahhabists, who fulminated the attack and America wanted blood. So, Afghanistan was an acceptable limited conflict that worked until Big Army decided that it needed to be there in a Big way — forever.

But I digress. On with the news.

On 18 May, Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) and Afghanistan’s National Directorate of Security (NDS) signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU), according to a statement released by Pakistan. The Director General, Inter Service Public Relations (ISPR), Major General Asim Bajwa, tweeted that the MoU includes intelligence sharing as well as complementary and coordinated operations and patrols on the respective sides of the border. 

The MoU and the coordinated border operations appear to update and amend the arrangements that existed between the US/NATO command in Afghanistan and Pakistan. They are positive developments, but signify no breakthrough in relations. They cover developments on the periphery of Afghanistan, when the fight has moved increasingly to Kabul.

Open sources attest to the steady progress the Taliban and their allies have made in executing attacks in Kabul. 
Insurgency and insurrection usually are centripetal. That means attacks in the capital are a critical measure for evaluating insurgent progress against the government. If the center does not hold, the insurgents win. The Afghan center – Kabul — is not holding; it is slowly collapsing. 
Pakistan created the Taliban and militarily supported their initial take-over of Afghanistan. Therefore this is consistent with their moves going back to the mid-1990’s. Pakistan is investing so it cannot lose, no matter the outcome. It has never stopped supporting the Afghan Taliban by providing a safe haven for the Afghan Taliban leadership during the past 14 years. The new arrangements with the Ghani government in Afghanistan are attempts to manipulate the Afghan government in Pakistan’s favor. This is a win-win strategy for Pakistan.

12 thoughts on “Is Afghanistan Lost?

  1. On days when my blood pressure is under control, I wander over to a leftist/(P)regressive site.
    The constant theme is that of "feelings", facts be damned. We shouldn't ignore the power of feelings, especially when they are married to perceived success. As to Afghanistan, my only "feeling" is relief my youngest son survived his tour.

  2. I was feeling mellow and ready for progleft tomfoolery, so I clicked on the link. Didn't work!

    Maybe just as well.

    Glad your son got back.

  3. Good Saudi point, LL.

    With friends like ours, who needs the, er, enemies that are our friends.

    But you're a man of influence. Get USGOV to take over the Magic Kingdom and all its oil. It should be ours anyway. And we could demolish their meteorite while we're at it — like Charlamagne and Yggdrasil.

    Just a thought.

  4. Thank you for the kind thoughts on my son. He is medically retired now so no more deployments. Mixed emotions. Would I rather he is safe or healthy?

  5. My son-in-law is medically retired from the US Navy after his tour in Afghanistan.

  6. I have good friends from Pakistan. Loyal friends. But the country is troubled and angry and I don't see any solution.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to top